If a topic is in any way controversial, there’s a good chance it will get removed, when I’m sure the same content wouldn’t get removed on Reddit. I know it depends on subs and instances but I mean more generally, and for example AskLemmy vs AskReddit. Reddit seems to have more leeway for things, whereas Lemmy doesn’t and seems harder on censorship. Not only that but they remove things even when they’re not controversial such as when I just asked a question about savory fruit and sweet vegetables that got removed. They also give no reason at all for why things get removed nor any notice of its removal until you realise later. It happens so frequently that I wonder if this post will get removed too for some reason.
They also give no reason at all
There’s an automated bot in LW that sends users the reason for why their content got removed or why they got banned, etc. Not only that, but every communities modlogs are public. You either could have received a reason by the bot or you could have checked the modlogs. And also, the title or the content is not the only factor I take into account when I remove someone’s post. I, for example, also consider how the OP behaves in the comments section to determine if the post is made just for the OP to troll people or not. I might also lock the post if the post gets too many reports or there’s too much drama going on in the comments section.
And by the way, the reason why I deleted it for rule 3 is very obvious:
2 days ago mod Removed Post What are the best sweet vegetables and savory fruits? reason: rule 3 and 5I imagine the moderator feels that you are flooding the community with nonsense as described in the rule about spam. It’s likely that moderators in communities with fewer posts and fewer voters take a more active role in removing content they feel is low-quality, while post volume and voting would hide such content from most users in a higher-volume community.
They also give no reason at all for why things get removed
reason: rule 3 and 5
yeah but…
🙄
So how do we determine if a question is nonsense? I didn’t realise the questions had to be necessarily important
One part of it that hasn’t been mentioned here yet is that admins moderate the moderating of moderators more. As a mod, I’ve gotten admins for example asking me why the inbox has been unchecked after a few days. The place I think is trying not to repeat Reddit’s “anarchy” if that’s the right word to use.
I wish this site was more like Reddit’s anarchy tbh lol. I see it as essentially a free speech platform aside from extreme cases.
