Then what the fuck do you say “it’s a meme” for? What useful information does that convey? Because clearly you’re serious about it and have been told that that response comes off as you saying “it’s just a joke bro”
Look mate, “it’s a meme” means it’s not going to be particularly nuanced in its criticism. It’s meant to ellicit cheap laughs through simplifying some parts. Y’all have a brain, you can certainly see which parts are exagerrated for these purposes. Your comrades were certainly capable of starting nuanced discussions about Catalonia based on this understanding.
Honestly, I think you are all playing dumb in order to get some gotchas.
I have no interest in gotchas, what I am seeking is a clear and consistent position. Obviously others who know more about the Spanish Civil War know that it’s depiction of Stalin as killing anarchists rather than merely supplying them with 75% of their tanks and no more is a wild misrepresentation, and you still have yet to clarify who the “intellectuals” in Mao’s case even refer to.
My further point is that this bizarre blanket characterization of MLs as butchers, including of people that they did nothing but help, is gross historical revisionism pandering to the preconceptions of people who frankly have next to zero historical understanding when it comes to the groups it refers to. It is in fact poor conduct to stand by such a message whether it is “just a meme” or communicated by any other medium, just as I am very careful to limit my accusations of, say, Nestor Makhno only to what the most sympathetic of biographers admit of him (since I personally do not know about the proof of other claims).
I don’t particularly have to play by your personal rules. For me the original meme is exagerrating historic events (I already explained why) in order to make a simple point “Don’t believe in left unity and be wary of tankies”. This is the part I agree with. And before you ask, I don’t have to justify myself to anyone, especially when they’re typical condescending MLs.
I left the comments open so y’all can counter all the claims in the meme in as much depth you want. I literally gave you full platform access. Y’all prefer to use it to shitpost instead 🤷
You are accusing someone of killing people that he did nothing but help, but simply helped inadequately.
You have no idea who the “intellectuals” even are, do you?
If you’re a leftist, don’t you think promoting red scare myths is probably bad for understanding history.
Edit: I will repeat what I said a while ago that I have never said that you have to do anything. It is a classic deflection to change the question of what you should do to what you can do. You can do anything you want, deny the Holocaust to own the tankies, I can’t stop you, but that doesn’t mean you should.
Complete aside, I would never tar anarchists like you tar MLs. There are many anarchists, like Sholem Schwartzbard, who I think were admirable in action and character, and MLs learning from anarchists as Mao did was a good thing.
If you’re a leftist, don’t you think promoting red scare myths is probably bad for understanding history.
I don’t know how many times I have explained what “this is a meme” means. It’s never going to be perfectly accurate or nuanced. There’s plenty examples of tankies directly sabotaging and killing anarchists which makes many many anarchists not trust left unity. I don’t understand why this is such a difficult idea to maintain.
You shouldn’t need to fabricate history to make that point then. The difference between “not giving someone enough tanks” and “summarily executing them” is not merely a matter of “perfect nuance and accuracy”, it is a morbid fantasy.
Also it’s just sort of poor form to make claims about things you have no idea about, like Mao and the “intellectuals”
Lastly, I’ll repost the late second edit you probably missed from earlier:
Complete aside, I would never tar anarchists like you tar MLs. There are many anarchists, like Sholem Schwartzbard, who I think were admirable in action and character, and MLs learning from anarchists as Mao did was a good thing.
You shouldn’t need to fabricate history to make that point then. The difference between “not giving someone enough tanks” and “summarily executing them” is not merely a matter of “perfect nuance and accuracy”, it is a morbid fantasy.
Also it’s just sort of poor form to make claims about things you have no idea about, like Mao and the “intellectuals”
Arglgbl, I just crossposted the meme, at the spur of the moment no less. I didn’t make it! I felt that it was an exagerration but nevertheless good enough for a meme. Cheezus.
Complete aside, I would never tar anarchists like you tar MLs. There are many anarchists, like Sholem Schwartzbard, who I think were admirable in action and character, and MLs learning from anarchists as Mao did was a good thing.
Very noble of you, but A) you don’t know my lived experiences with tankies, and B) MLs calling anarchists immature, naive and being generally insufferably patronizing is probably older than Lenin and basically the total experience I’ve had with hexbear the last 2 days :D
Arglgbl, I just crossposted the meme, at the spur of the moment no less. I didn’t make it! I felt that it was an exagerration but nevertheless good enough for a meme. Cheezus.
Then the recommendation I’d offer is to not cross-post shit that’s bad. You probably didn’t know the history of Catalonia (there were things in the discussion that I don’t know), but just sort of went off of a cold war vibe in your head that most murder accusations of MLs are probably true “enough”. You certainly made at least a bare effort, after it was pointed out to you, to make the meme less racist, but you showed no interest in making even the same guy have a remotely true mass-murder accusation next to his name.
Also the whole “MLs calling for left-unity” thing is, well, ahistorical aside from the United Front, which worked out perfectly well for its purpose of fighting the Nazis. Hexbear says that, but the figures listed did not (idk about Khrushchev, but fuck him).
So it’s basically just contempt completely warping your view to the point of accusing people of lies when they neither said what you claim nor did what you claim after.
but A) you don’t know my lived experiences with tankies,
They sure as shit didn’t murder you. Were your buddies subjected to some 21st century ML firing squad that I’ve never heard of?
MLs calling anarchists immature, naive and being generally insufferably patronizing
You know what all this is? Not murder! You’d still get complaints from people who can’t take a joke, but if you just called MLs patronizing to start with, you’d actually have a valid point
There’s plenty examples of tankies directly sabotaging and killing anarchists
Then put those on the meme instead of the blatant falsehoods that are there. Like, sorry, but “oh, it’s a meme it doesn’t have to be accurate” is a terrible argument for posting a misleading, anti-communist meme. Just make a better meme, it’s not hard
Can you blame me for thinking you care what hexbears think about you? Like, look at this thread we’re posting in, look at the meme you started it with (I’m assuming you made this one). It sure seems like you care, and that’s ok! I also care what hexbears think about me, even though I’ll never meet these weirdo nerds in real life.
Also, if you didn’t make the meme and you agree it’s anti-communist misinformation, then why post it? And why defend it so vigorously when people point out the misinformation?
Anyway, I have to actually stop putting work off now, so I likely won’t be responding to you for at least several hours. I sincerely hope you have a good day, don’t let internet arguments get you down too much, ok? The internet is a toxic shithole and it’s very, very easy to escalate arguments way too far, even with people who you really have more in common with than not. I know I do it.
My life doesn’t revolve around what hexbears might think of me.
It wasn’t an appeal to you being concerned about what hexbears think, it was an appeal to your own sense of what decent conduct is, since you presumably don’t want to mislead your fellow anarchists with completely false myths.
Then what the fuck do you say “it’s a meme” for? What useful information does that convey? Because clearly you’re serious about it and have been told that that response comes off as you saying “it’s just a joke bro”
Look mate, “it’s a meme” means it’s not going to be particularly nuanced in its criticism. It’s meant to ellicit cheap laughs through simplifying some parts. Y’all have a brain, you can certainly see which parts are exagerrated for these purposes. Your comrades were certainly capable of starting nuanced discussions about Catalonia based on this understanding.
Honestly, I think you are all playing dumb in order to get some gotchas.
I have no interest in gotchas, what I am seeking is a clear and consistent position. Obviously others who know more about the Spanish Civil War know that it’s depiction of Stalin as killing anarchists rather than merely supplying them with 75% of their tanks and no more is a wild misrepresentation, and you still have yet to clarify who the “intellectuals” in Mao’s case even refer to.
My further point is that this bizarre blanket characterization of MLs as butchers, including of people that they did nothing but help, is gross historical revisionism pandering to the preconceptions of people who frankly have next to zero historical understanding when it comes to the groups it refers to. It is in fact poor conduct to stand by such a message whether it is “just a meme” or communicated by any other medium, just as I am very careful to limit my accusations of, say, Nestor Makhno only to what the most sympathetic of biographers admit of him (since I personally do not know about the proof of other claims).
I don’t particularly have to play by your personal rules. For me the original meme is exagerrating historic events (I already explained why) in order to make a simple point “Don’t believe in left unity and be wary of tankies”. This is the part I agree with. And before you ask, I don’t have to justify myself to anyone, especially when they’re typical condescending MLs.
I left the comments open so y’all can counter all the claims in the meme in as much depth you want. I literally gave you full platform access. Y’all prefer to use it to shitpost instead 🤷
You are accusing someone of killing people that he did nothing but help, but simply helped inadequately.
You have no idea who the “intellectuals” even are, do you?
If you’re a leftist, don’t you think promoting red scare myths is probably bad for understanding history.
Edit: I will repeat what I said a while ago that I have never said that you have to do anything. It is a classic deflection to change the question of what you should do to what you can do. You can do anything you want, deny the Holocaust to own the tankies, I can’t stop you, but that doesn’t mean you should.
Complete aside, I would never tar anarchists like you tar MLs. There are many anarchists, like Sholem Schwartzbard, who I think were admirable in action and character, and MLs learning from anarchists as Mao did was a good thing.
I don’t know how many times I have explained what “this is a meme” means. It’s never going to be perfectly accurate or nuanced. There’s plenty examples of tankies directly sabotaging and killing anarchists which makes many many anarchists not trust left unity. I don’t understand why this is such a difficult idea to maintain.
You shouldn’t need to fabricate history to make that point then. The difference between “not giving someone enough tanks” and “summarily executing them” is not merely a matter of “perfect nuance and accuracy”, it is a morbid fantasy.
Also it’s just sort of poor form to make claims about things you have no idea about, like Mao and the “intellectuals”
Lastly, I’ll repost the late second edit you probably missed from earlier:
Arglgbl, I just crossposted the meme, at the spur of the moment no less. I didn’t make it! I felt that it was an exagerration but nevertheless good enough for a meme. Cheezus.
Very noble of you, but A) you don’t know my lived experiences with tankies, and B) MLs calling anarchists immature, naive and being generally insufferably patronizing is probably older than Lenin and basically the total experience I’ve had with hexbear the last 2 days :D
Then the recommendation I’d offer is to not cross-post shit that’s bad. You probably didn’t know the history of Catalonia (there were things in the discussion that I don’t know), but just sort of went off of a cold war vibe in your head that most murder accusations of MLs are probably true “enough”. You certainly made at least a bare effort, after it was pointed out to you, to make the meme less racist, but you showed no interest in making even the same guy have a remotely true mass-murder accusation next to his name.
Also the whole “MLs calling for left-unity” thing is, well, ahistorical aside from the United Front, which worked out perfectly well for its purpose of fighting the Nazis. Hexbear says that, but the figures listed did not (idk about Khrushchev, but fuck him).
So it’s basically just contempt completely warping your view to the point of accusing people of lies when they neither said what you claim nor did what you claim after.
They sure as shit didn’t murder you. Were your buddies subjected to some 21st century ML firing squad that I’ve never heard of?
You know what all this is? Not murder! You’d still get complaints from people who can’t take a joke, but if you just called MLs patronizing to start with, you’d actually have a valid point
Then put those on the meme instead of the blatant falsehoods that are there. Like, sorry, but “oh, it’s a meme it doesn’t have to be accurate” is a terrible argument for posting a misleading, anti-communist meme. Just make a better meme, it’s not hard
I didn’t make the meme. I didn’t plan to make a meme. My life doesn’t revolve around what hexbears might think of me.
Can you blame me for thinking you care what hexbears think about you? Like, look at this thread we’re posting in, look at the meme you started it with (I’m assuming you made this one). It sure seems like you care, and that’s ok! I also care what hexbears think about me, even though I’ll never meet these weirdo nerds in real life.
Also, if you didn’t make the meme and you agree it’s anti-communist misinformation, then why post it? And why defend it so vigorously when people point out the misinformation?
Anyway, I have to actually stop putting work off now, so I likely won’t be responding to you for at least several hours. I sincerely hope you have a good day, don’t let internet arguments get you down too much, ok? The internet is a toxic shithole and it’s very, very easy to escalate arguments way too far, even with people who you really have more in common with than not. I know I do it.
It wasn’t an appeal to you being concerned about what hexbears think, it was an appeal to your own sense of what decent conduct is, since you presumably don’t want to mislead your fellow anarchists with completely false myths.