• 61 Posts
  • 18 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: September 13th, 2023

help-circle

  • I built a one-shot around this idea on a heavily-modded Tiny D6 system, letting people choose which of the 4 they wanted to be with variants like wealthy or scientific Victorian, captain or gunner pirate, disgraced or retired Samurai, cattle driver or 49’er, and so forth. I set it in San Francisco to get some good conflux of cultures.

    Of my 4 players, 3 of them chose to be rich Victorians. facepalm

































  • Eh, I’d definitely say it’s not a “don’t ever do this” scenario. For player agency matters- if luck had been on our side (if I’d rolled a longer fuse, if we’d coordinated better, if I’d gone down instead of up first) then yeah, we could have diffused them. Regardless, I think it works for the story. First off, it’s something I gave myself in my backstory, not something I earned in-game. Secondly, I acknowledged that having this bar to defend was reducing my character’s desire to go after the main story line (so I shouldn’t have been surprised ;) ). Third, this is intended as a short campaign so I think bigger character’s-life-changing events are reasonable if not even expected. And most importantly of course, I trust my DM to make a good story, and he trusts me to help move the story forward in interesting ways. (despite what I said about defending the bar, I can find character reasons to move forward if I need to and have in the past.)