Do you think it will be possible to run GNU/Linux operating systems on Microsoft’s brand new “Copilot+ PCs”? The latter ones were unveiled just yesterday, and honestly, the sales pitch is quite impressive! A Verge article on them: Link
Yes, Linux actually does already run on ARM chips, and Qualcomm themselves pledged support for Linux for the new chips within the next 6 months.
There is one big issue though: most applications won’t be available since they have to work specifically for ARM. This is a big deal because I don’t think Linux has a proper x86 --> ARM translation layer. That means most of your apps and games won’t work.
I’d wait at least a couple of months to see how the ecosystem is before buying one. It’s likely going to be a very bumpy ride for the next ~2 years until everything you’d need is supported.
Most applications are/can be compiled for arm. You just need the right repo or to compile from source.
Raspberry pi’s are very popular and are arm based already.
You don’t need a translation layer unless the software is proprietary and the vendor isn’t willing to compile for arm.
Most applications are/can be compiled for arm. You just need the right repo or to compile from source.
Maybe the essentials like browsers and CMD tools are available for ARM, but I’m talking about applications in general. Almost all of Flatpak won’t work, not everyone will bother compiling for ARM and those that do probably won’t do so as soon as these laptops release. You’d have to be a real poweruser to compile stuff from source and not suffer. Not to mention proprietary stuff that are already reluctant to support Linux, imagine how long it’ll take for things like Zoom and Discord to get official support. Before anyone hits me with the “those don’t matter”, it does to a lot of people.
You don’t need a translation layer unless the software is proprietary and the vendor isn’t willing to compile for arm.
Even then, there will be tons of legacy apps people will want to run.
Have you looked? Almost all software on flathub (definitely the majority) lists aarch64 (ARM). So yes, most things work.
Again, proprietary software is the main issue here. Open source software is pretty easy to recompile.
I understand qemu can emulate x86 in those cases, with a performance hit.
Wow. That settles the discussion pretty quickly…
I’m not sure with the transition layer… Isn’t there things like qemu and box64… And multiarch support is part of most of the Linux distributions as of today? I always thought it’s just a few commands to make your system execute foreign binaries. I mean I’ve only ever tried cross-compiling for arm and running 32bit games on amd64 architecture so I don’t know that much. In the end I don’t use that much proprietary software, so it’s not really any issue for me. >99% of Linux software I use is available for ARM. But I can see how that’d be an issue for a gamer, regardless of the operating system being Windows or Linux or MacOS.
And I’m not really interested in the AI coprocessor itself. The real question for me is: Can it do LLM inference as fast as a M2/M3 Macbook? For that it’d need RAM that’s connected via a wide bus. And then there’s the question what does a machine with 64GB of RAM cost. That’s the major drawback with a Macbook because they get super expensive if you want a decent amount of RAM.
Isn’t there things like qemu and box64…
Yeah, but they’re experimental and probably very buggy. I’ve used box64 on my phone, it doesn’t play well with everything.
Can it do LLM inference as fast as a M2/M3 Macbook?
It should be better at AI stuff than M series laptops, allegedly. Many manufacturers actually started listing their prices for the new laptops, the new Microsoft ones start at 16GB of RAM at $1000. I know the Lenovo one can reach 64GB of RAM but not sure about the pricing.
Hmmh. I can’t really make an informed statement. I can’t fathom qemu being experimental. That’s like a 20 year old project and used by lots of people. I’m not sure. And I’ve yet to try Box64.
I looked it up. The Snapdragin X Elite “Supports up to 64GB LPDDR5, with 136 GB/s memory bandwidth” while the Apple M2/M3 have anywhere from 100 GB/s memory bandwith to 150/300 or 400. (800 in the Ultra). And a graphics card has like ~300 to ~1000GB/s)
(Of course that’s only relevant for running large language models.)
I really don’t see why all the companies would lock down the bios so you couldn’t install a new os. Also seems like Qualcomm is supporting linux, although probably will take a year for it to be properly supported.
