Lemmy is certainly a lot faster than new reddit, but I prefer the aesthetic and speed of old.reddit.com and hackernews. I like the minimalism and how everything defaults to the left of the browser rather than the center. I also really enjoy how I can expand the entire text of a post without actually clicking on the post’s link.

Just my thoughts. Hoping to see more theme and front-end options emerge over time.

  • Cosmic Frog@lemmy.mlEnglish
    1·
    2 years ago

    Let’s say I start with something simple, like moving everything to the left of the screen instead of centering it. People like OP and me would like that, but from the POV of the lemmy devs, that’s quite a shit PR, isn’t it?

    I would rather have a web client that can go in a different direction UI-wise, and if they like anything there, they can take it for the main web UI. And of course, there are many other advantages of a client, like using multiple accounts from different instances.

    Edit: I also like the idea of a simple client anyone can fork and modify to their taste.

    • UrbenLegend@lemmy.mlEnglish
      1·
      2 years ago

      People like OP and me would like that, but from the POV of the lemmy devs, that’s quite a shit PR, isn’t it?

      Well you gotta do some integration work obviously instead of just changing the theme outright. Maybe add in a easy way to set themes and layout. Default will be whatever main Lemmy devs think is good, and optional settings that allow a style that OP wants.

      It’s simpler than creating a whole separate client and then also having to maintain it whenever Lemmy’s backend changes or when they introduce a new feature.

      • Cosmic Frog@lemmy.mlEnglish
        2·
        2 years ago

        Looking at the conversations they are having on GitHub, that doesn’t seem like a great idea. If I was going to contribute to the main repo, it would be to help with whatever they are doing, not to push ideas that they are not looking to implement at this time. They are working on rewriting the UI anyway. I really don’t see what would be the problem with having an alternative front for people with different tastes that those of the devs.

        It’s simpler than creating a whole separate client

        Maybe. But I wasn’t really looking for the simplest way to tweak the UI, I’m already doing that with my own scripts. Making a web client with a different UI that people can fork and make their own just sounds like a cool project to work on.