For as long as schools have policed hairstyles as part of their dress codes, some students have seen the rules as attempts to deny their cultural and religious identities.
Nowhere have school rules on hair been a bigger flashpoint than in Texas, where a trial this week is set to determine whether high school administrators can continue punishing a Black teenager for refusing to cut his hair. The 18-year-old student, Darryl George, who wears his hair in locs tied atop his head, has been kept out of his classroom since the start of the school year.
To school administrators, strict dress codes can be tools for promoting uniformity and discipline. But advocates say the codes disproportionately affect students of color and the punishments disrupt learning. Under pressure, many schools in Texas have removed boys-only hair length rules, while hundreds of districts maintain hair restrictions written into their dress codes.
Schools that enforce strict dress codes have higher rates of punishment that take students away from learning, such as suspensions and expulsions, according to an October 2022 report from the Government Accountability Office. The report called on the U.S. Department of Education to provide resources to help schools design more equitable dress codes.
I think some codes are reasonable, mainly those that promote hygiene, which kids are notoriously bad at.
There is no helping children’s hygiene except through education, rules won’t do shit
Rules are an enforcement method instilling education of the consequences of not following the rules.
can you give me some examples of that? I’ve never seen a policy that your clothes had to be clean but maybe that’s because I never went to look for that sort of thing
It’s not school rule. It’s parenting rule to provide your kid with clean clothes as much as you can, or at least, it should be.
I’ve never heard of it and didn’t realize it was necessary. dark if true
Did your parents never tell you to keep your clothes clean for school? That’s just normal parenting, how’s that dark?
it’s dark to think that some kids go to school wearing dirty clothes and so there’s a policy against it
holy shit lemmy is stupid
Well it was not clear what you were referring to. The comment you replied was talking about the rules, not the kids wearing dirty clothes.
Since when Lemmy got full of pretentious twats that label everyone stupid for having a misunderstanding that is clearly their fault?
dark if true
why?
Even the military has recognized that certain hairstyles are worse on different ethnicities hair, and has subsequently relaxed the standards since I’ve been active.
The military, which is all about uniformity and “discipline”, can see that different cultures have different hair treatments/needs, and not everything has to be “all Caucasian, all the time”.
And yet our K-12 schools can’t seem to do that?! Like wtf?
I went to highschool for 1 year in the UK, where a uniform was mandatory for every student.
I can assure you, it does not promote discipline in any way. Kids fight, do stupid things, and skip classes regardless of how they’re dressed.
I’ve been teaching for almost 20 years. Dress codes do not promote discipline whatsoever. Administrators mete out disciplinary measures when students don’t follow the dress code, to be sure, but the only thing the dress code serves to do is promote conformity.
Dress codes, while promoting conformity, also allow students to breathe easier knowing that they don’t have to worry about keeping up with expensive brand name trends in clothing. A school uniform is a great equalizer and can remove the classist element, the bullying that can occur, that students from lower socio economic backgrounds face.
Have you ever seen the kids shoes. Some have some expensive Air Jordan’s and others might be wearing gold trumps. They know who has the money just by looking down.
In my school uniform included shoes (or at least they had to be of a certain colour). True, you will know who is rich anyway, but the point of the uniform was not to hide who was wealthy, but instead level all clothes and avoid flashing.
Personally, although I think uniforms don’t serve their purpose, and kids are better off wearing whatever they want, I loved that I didn’t have to think about what to wear when going to school.
Why would hair, a part of a person’s body, be a part of a dress code? White people are fucking insane…
how else would discriminate against “people” (hint: they don’t see dark skinned people as people)
Ooh, ooh, how about complaining about their accent and choice of slang! No way that’s going to be racist wink wink nudge nudge
I would have argued against this as a kid, but having since taught overseas in places with school uniforms, I would say that’s the way to go.
Dictating hairstyles to too much though. Particularly when you consider the variety of hair types you’re going to see in a diverse country like the U.S.
Incorrect. Dress codes are racist and classicist also often the sign of someone trying to groom someone else. You got to be a real fucking sicko to demand a bunch of preteens wear short skirts.
I don’t think you realise school uniforms are not like they are shown in anime or by Britney spears
I don’t think you realize that I wore one.
I come from a country with school uniforms and I hated it.
Felt more like a way to control us and/or it was all about the schoool’s image.
Our hair had to follow certain rules, short, no colour, no gel.
we never had hair restrictions … that I bumped up against (even with wild colours) … and getting detention for non sanctioned clothing was a badge of honor. I basically spent my entire final year in a trench coat, and maybe Columbine helped me out a little bit there, but honestly the whole 90’s was basically a class on how to subvert the school dress code for me and my classmates.
but I guess if you lack imagination it could be a bit stifling not being able to get your personality off the rack.