Me watching it has nothing to do with my questions above. Please read them properly.
Unless what you propose is that hamas watched that video, got back in time with the knowledge that “this time Israel will do such a thing” and attacked…
I think calling that demonstration peaceful is at least a simplification but let’s forget that.
“Asking less nicely” you say. But I don’t see proofs of that really being the purpose of hamas actions. Asking in a way that would not lead to further deaths of your own people should have been the way.
Yet they were building rockets instead of defenses all this time. If they couldnt eradicate all that they needed/wanted (the whole Israel I guess) why even start something like the October 7 attack?
Are you comparing Israel to nazi? It doesn’t seem like they were doing a nice job at genociding as the Palestinians population was increasing steadily during last years.
I’m asking again, about the basic logic of any actions. Whoever planned the October 7 attack, were not going for success. If they valued lives of Palestinians (their own) they would do something else, or use something else.
Israel is currently killing more children in Palestine each day than the Nazi’s did in one of their biggest concentration camps at the height of the Holocaust.
Yes I am comparing israel to the Nazi’s. That is the most apt comparison.
Yeah you mean after the October 7. Reading your comments, hamas were shocked by current events and decided to do that attack. The scenario is missing a time machine though. And possibly some logic.
We may as well see Putin announcing that he started the war because NATO decided to expand through Finland.
Genocide or not, the ground operation had a starting point which is October 7. Whatever happened then was not what Israeli wanted.
My point is to try to find an explanation for actions of hamas other than their desire to have many more Palestinians killed. They are humans and therefore no strangers to logic, so I want to get a sense of it.
Me watching it has nothing to do with my questions above. Please read them properly.
Unless what you propose is that hamas watched that video, got back in time with the knowledge that “this time Israel will do such a thing” and attacked…
Hamas tried a peaceful demonstration in 2018 and then got brutally slaughtered by israel so now they’re asking less nicely.
I think calling that demonstration peaceful is at least a simplification but let’s forget that.
“Asking less nicely” you say. But I don’t see proofs of that really being the purpose of hamas actions. Asking in a way that would not lead to further deaths of your own people should have been the way.
Yet they were building rockets instead of defenses all this time. If they couldnt eradicate all that they needed/wanted (the whole Israel I guess) why even start something like the October 7 attack?
How do you think the Nazi’s went away?
Did we ask them very nicely to stop Genociding?
Are you comparing Israel to nazi? It doesn’t seem like they were doing a nice job at genociding as the Palestinians population was increasing steadily during last years.
I’m asking again, about the basic logic of any actions. Whoever planned the October 7 attack, were not going for success. If they valued lives of Palestinians (their own) they would do something else, or use something else.
Israel is currently killing more children in Palestine each day than the Nazi’s did in one of their biggest concentration camps at the height of the Holocaust.
Yes I am comparing israel to the Nazi’s. That is the most apt comparison.
Yeah you mean after the October 7. Reading your comments, hamas were shocked by current events and decided to do that attack. The scenario is missing a time machine though. And possibly some logic.
We may as well see Putin announcing that he started the war because NATO decided to expand through Finland.
What is the point of this Hasbara jumbo? You are admitting israel is committing Genocide and blaming the Hamas?
Go back and read the meme at the top.
Genocide or not, the ground operation had a starting point which is October 7. Whatever happened then was not what Israeli wanted.
My point is to try to find an explanation for actions of hamas other than their desire to have many more Palestinians killed. They are humans and therefore no strangers to logic, so I want to get a sense of it.